A List of Unprovenanced, Post-2002 Dead Sea Scrolls-like Fragments

[First version: 11 August 2016]

[Organized According to the Protestant Old Testament Canon]

This list builds upon Eibert Tigchelaar’s authoritative list, “A Provisional List of Unprovenanced, Twenty-First Century, Dead Sea Scrolls-like Fragments” (version 1.0; April 16, 2016; version 2; September 18, 2016), but is organized differently.

Statistical observations
NB! Only the fragments that have been “identified”, i.e. nos 1–72, form part of my statistics.

– 86%  (89 % with Tobit) of the Post-2002 Dead Sea Scrolls-like frgs are “biblical”  (cf. Tigchelaar, version 2.0, 2: “Remarkable in this list is the very high number of fragments containing sections of biblical texts …”).

47 of the 62 biblical fragments, i.e. 76%, contain excerpts from 2-4 Bible verses. The distribution is as follows:

1 verse: 4 frgs

2 verses: 12 frgs

3 verses: 19 frgs

4 verses: 16 frgs

5 verses: 2 frgs

6 verses: 2 frgs

7 verses: 2 frg

8 verses: 2 frgs

10 or more verses: 3 frgs


Bibliography
Carroll, Scott. “Stones and Scriptures.” Seminar at CCF Center, Manila, 23 February, 2018.
Charlesworth, James H. “Jeremiah 48:29-31a [Provisional Research Report].” May, 2010.
Elgvin, Torleif, Kipp Davis, and Michael Langlois, eds. Gleanings From the Caves: Dead Sea Scrolls and Artefacts from The Schøyen Collection. LTST 71. London: Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2016.
Eshel, Esther, and Hanan Eshel. “A New Fragment of the Book of the Watchers from Qumran (XQpapEnoch).” Tarbiz 73 (2004): 171–79 [Hebrew]; V [English Abstract].
Eshel, Esther, Hanan Eshel, and Magen Broshi. “A New Fragment of XJudges.” DSD 14 (2007): 354–58.
Eshel, Esther, and Hanan Eshel. “A Preliminary Report on Seven New Fragments from Qumran.” Meghillot 5-6 (2007): 271-78.
_____. “New Fragments from Qumran: 4QGenf, 4QIsab, 4Q226, 8QGen, and XQpapEnoch.” DSD 12 (2005): 134–57.
Fields, Weston, “Dead Sea Scrolls: Significance of the Latest Developments.” The Lanier Library Lecture Series, 16 April, 2011.
Flint, Peter W. “Unrolling the Dead Sea Psalms Scrolls.” Pages 229–50 in The Oxford Handbook of the Psalms. Edited by William P. Brown. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2014.
Hallermayer, Michaela, and Torleif Elgvin. “Schøyen ms. 5234: Ein neues Tobit-Fragment vom Toten Meer.” RevQ 22/87 (2006): 451–61.
Johnson, Michael B. “A Case Study in Professional Ethics Concerning Secondary Publications of Unprovenanced Artefacts: The New Edition DSS F.Instruction1.” Distant Worlds Journal 2 (2017): 28–42.
Parry, Donald, and Emanuel Tov, eds. The Dead Sea Scrolls Reader: Part 3: Parabiblical Texts. Leiden: Brill, 2005.
Parry, Donald, and Emanuel Tov, eds. The Dead Sea Scrolls Reader: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded. 2 Vols. Leiden: Brill, 2014.
Puech, Emile. “Notes sur le manuscrit des Juges 4Q50a.” RevQ 21 (2003): 315–19.
_____. “Un nouveau fragment 7a de 4QGn-Exa = 4QGen-Ex 1 et quelques nouvelles lectures et identifications du manuscrit 4Q1.” RevQ 25/97 (2011): 103–11.
Tigchelaar, Eibert. “A Provisional List of Unprovenanced, Twenty-First Century, Dead Sea Scrolls-like Fragments.” DSD 24 (2017): 173–88.
Tov, Emanuel. Revised List of Texts from the Judaean Desert. Leiden: Brill, 2010.
Tov, Emanuel, Kipp Davis, and Robert Duke, eds. Dead Sea Scrolls Fragments in the Museum Collection. Publications of Museum of the Bible 1. Leiden: Brill, 2016.

No. Content Designations Effects on the DSS dataset Collector(s)/ collection(s)
1 Gen 13:1–3 Wrongly identified as 8Q1 (8QGen) frg. 1a 1–3 by Eshel & Eshel 2005 (= Accordance)

William Kando ➤ Craig (& Joel) Lampe (2003–4)

2 Words from Genesis 22 dss01
“Genesis Midrash”
Wrongly identified as 4Q226 (4QpsJubb) frg. 6a 1–4 by Eshel & Eshel 2005 → Parry & Tov 2005 (= Accordance) + Parry & Tov 2014 → Tov 2010: 37 William Kando →
Lee Biondi & Bruce Ferrini † ➤ William Noah (June 2004)
3 Gen 31:23–25?, 32:3–6 motb.scr.000124
DSS F.191 (Gen2)
Acquired by James Charlesworth 25 Oct 2006(?)

Michael Sharpe ➤ Steve Green (Feb 2010) → Museum of the Bible

4 Gen 33:19–34:2 Wrongly identified as 4Q6 (4QGenf) frg. 1a 1–3 by Eshel & Eshel 2005  (= Accordance) Tov 2010: 22
William Kando
5 Gen 36:7–16 MS 4612/4
DSS F.101 (Gen1)
4Q(?)GenMiniature  (Elgvin 2016) William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2009)
6 Gen 37:8 MS 5439/1
DSS F.102 (RP1)
Wrongly identified as 4Q1 (4QGn-Exa) frg. 7a by Puech 2011 and as 4QRPb (4Q364) frg. 8a by Elgvin 2016 William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (May 2010)
7 Gen 37:26–38 “Butterfly fragment” 4Q601=4QGen37–38 (K) (Fields) William Kando
8 Exod 3:13–15 MS 4612/2a
DSS F.103 (Exod3)
Wrongly identified as 4Q14 (4QExodc) frg. 1a 1–3 by Eshel & Eshel 2007 (=Accordance) →  Tov 2010: 22–23 William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2003–4)
9 Exod 5:9–14 MS 4612/2b
DSS F.104 (Exod4)
Wrongly identified as 4Q14 (4QExodc) frg. 1b 1–5 by Eshel & Eshel 2007 (=Accordance) →  Tov 2010: 22–23 William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2003–4)
 
10 Exod 12:3–5 William Kando → Scott Carroll
11 Exod 16:10 MS 4612/2c
DSS F.105 (Exod5)
 Wrongly identified as 4Q14 in Tov 2010: 22–23 William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2003–4)
12 Exod 17:4–7 motb.scr.000120
DSS F.192 (Exod6)
Cf. Tov 2010: 109, 126 William Kando ➤ Craig (& Joel) Lampe (2003–4) ➤ Steve Green (Nov 2009) → Museum of the Bible
13 Exod 18:6–8
[Tigchelaar: Hab 2:1–3?]
APU1
DSS F.151 (Unid) [earlier: DDS F.Exod1]
Cf. Tov 2010: 109, 126 Michael R. Thompson – Lee Biondi ➤
Azusa Pacific University (Aug 2009)
14 Exod 23:8–10 Mora fragment
DSS F.161 (Exod2)
Cf. Tov 2010: 109, 126 William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary (Jan 2010)
15 Lev 1:2–5 Lev 1:2–5 Bar Kochba Cf. Tov 2010: 109–10, 126 William Kando
16 Lev 10:4–7 APU2
DSS F.152 (Lev1)
Cf. Tov 2010: 109–10, 126 Michael R. Thompson – Lee Biondi ➤ Azusa Pacific University  (Aug 2009)
17 Lev 20:24, 18:28–30 Dearing Fragment
DSS F.162 (Lev2)
Wrongly identified  (and sold?) as 4QLevb
Cf. Tov 2010: 109–10, 126
William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary (Jan 2010)
18 Lev 23:4(?) motb.scr.000122
DSS F.193 (Lev5)
Cf. Tov 2010: 109–10, 126 William Kando ➤ Craig (& Joel) Lampe (2003–4) (→ James Charlesworth) ➤ Steve Green (Nov 2009) → Museum of the Bible
19 Lev 23:24–28 ncf.scr.004742
DSS F.203 (Lev6)
Andrew Stimer ➤ National Christian Foundation or Steve Green (Oct 2014-June 2015)→ Museum of the Bible
20 Lev 23:38–39 ArugLev frg. a  Accordance,
Tov 2010: 97, 126
Looters ➤ Hanan Eshel (Feb 2005) → Israel Antiquities Authority
21 Lev 23:40–44, 24:16–19 ArugLev frg. b-c Accordance,
Tov 2010: 97, 126
Looters ➤ Hanan Eshel (Feb 2005) → Israel Antiquities Authority
22 Num 8:3–5 motb.scr.003173
DSS F.194 (Num2)
William Kando ➤ Steve Green (May 2010) → Museum of the Bible
23 Num 16:2–5 MS 4612/5
DSS F.107 (Num1)
 Wrongly identified as 34Seiyal Numeri  by Hanan Eshel (2010). Elgvin 2016 labels it 4Q(?)Num William Kando ➤
Schøyen Collection
(2009)
24 Deut 6:1–2 MS 5214/1
DDS F.108 (Deut5)
 Wrongly identified as 4Q38 (Deutk1) frg. 1a by Eshel & Eshel  → Tov 2010: 25. Elgvin 2016 labels it 4Q(?)Deut1 William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2003)
25 Deut 8:2–5 APU3
DSS F.153 (Deut1)
 X15 (XDeuta)? (Tov 2010: 110, 127) Lee Biondi ➤ Azusa Pacific University (Aug 2009)
26 Deut 9:25–10:1 DSS F.163 (Deut3) Wrongly identified  (and sold?) as 4Q33 (4QDeutf)
X16 (XDeutb)? (Tov 2010: 110, 127)
William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
27 Deut 12:11–14 Rogers Fragment
DSS F.164 (Deut4)
 X17 (XDeutc)? (Tov 2010: 110, 127) William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary
28 Deut 19:13–15 (Eshel & Eshel 2007)
Deut 23:3–4 (Puech?; Charlesworth?)
 dss03 Wrongly identified as 4Q33 (4QDeutf) frg. 12a 1–3 by Eshel & Eshel 2007 (=Accordance) → Tov 2010: 25 William Kando → Lee Biondi & Bruce Ferrini † ➤ William Noah (June 2004)
29 Deut 27:4–6 APU4
DSS F.154 (Deut2)
 X18 (XDeutd) (Tov 2010: 110, 127) William Kando(?) ➤ Legacy Ministries International ➤
Azusa Pacific University (5 Aug 2009)
30 Deut 32:5–9 MS 5214/2
DSS F.109 (Deut6)
4Q(?)Deut2 (Elgvin 2016) William Kando ➤
Schøyen Collection (2009)
31 Judg 1:10–12 Wrongly labelled 4Q50a (4QJudgesa) by Puech 2003; XJudg frg. 1 (Eshel, Eshel & Broshi 2007)  (= Accordance) Tov 2010: 26 William Kando (→ Émile Puech)
32 Judg 4:6–8 XJudg frg. 7 (Eshel, Eshel & Broshi 2007) (= Accordance Tov 2010: 128 (→ Esther & Hanan Eshel)
33 Judg 19:10–13, 23–28 X19 (XJudgd) (Tov 2010: 110, 128) William Kando  Schøyen Collection (2010)
34 Ruth 2:1–2 MS 5441
DDS F.120 (Ruth1)
4Q(?)Ruth (Elgvin 2016) William Kando  Schøyen Collection (2010)
35 1 Sam 2:11–14 MS 4612/10
DSS F.112 (Sam1)
William Kando ➤  Schøyen Collection (2009)
36 1 Sam 5:10–11 MS 5480
DSS F.113 (Sam2)
4Q(?)Sam (Elgvin 2016) William Kando ➤  Schøyen Collection (2009)
37 2 Sam 20:22–24 MS 5233/1
DSS F.114 (Sam3)
Wrongly identified as 1Q7 (1QSam) frg. 3a by Hanan Eshel & Torleif Elgvin and as frg. 7a by Tov 2010: 6. Elgvin 2016 labels it XQ(?)Sam William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2003)
38 1 Kgs 13:20–22 DSS F.170 (Kings) William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary (2012?)
39 1 Kgs 16:23–26 MS 5440
DSS F.115 (Kgs1)
 4Q(?)Kgs (Elgvin 2016) William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2010)
40 Neh 2:13–16 motb.scr.003175
DSS F.201 (Neh2)
William Kando ➤ Steve Green (May 2010) Museum of the Bible
41 Neh 3:14–15 MS 5426
DSS F.122 (Neh1)
“Qumran Cave IV” (Charlesworth 2008); X25 (XNeh) (Tov 2010: 110, 129) William Kando (?) ➤ Lee Biondi (?) (→ James Charlesworth) ➤
Schøyen Collection (2009)
42 Ps 9:10, 12–13 MS 5233/2
DSS F.118 (Ps2)
XQPs A (Flint 2014); 4Q(?)Ps (Elgvin 2016) William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection
(2004)
43 Ps 11:1–4 motb.scr.000121
DSS F.199 (Ps3)
Wrongly identified as 11Q7 (11QPsc) frg. 3a by Eshel & Eshel 2007 (=Accordance) Tov 2010: 69. Flint 2014 labels it XQPs C
William Kando ➤ Craig (& Joel) Lampe (2002?) ➤ Green Collection (Nov 2009) → Museum of the Bible
44 Ps 11:1–3 Wrongly identified as 11QPsc (11Q7) frg. 3b by Eshel & Eshel 2007 (=Accordance) → Tov 2010: 69  William Kando ➤ Bruce Ferrini ➤ Ashland Theological Seminary (2004)
45 Ps 22:4, 6–9, 11–13 Patterson Fragment
DSS F.165 (Ps1)
4Q SWBTS Psalms (Fields 2011); XQPs B (Flint 2014) William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary (Sept 2010)
46 Prov 4:23–5:1 MS 4612/11
DSS F.119 (Prov1)
4Q(?)Prov (Elgvin 2016) William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2009)
47 Isa 24:16–17 dss04 Wrongly identified as 4Q56 (4QIsab) frg. 16a 1–2 by Eshel & Eshel 2005 (= Accordance) Tov 2010: 28. Tov (2010: 110) also seems to label this fragment X20 (XIsa) William Kando → Lee Biondi & Bruce Ferrini † ➤ William Noah (June 2004)
48 Isa 26:19–27:1 dss02 Wrongly identified as 4QIsab (4Q56) frg. 20a 1–5 by Eshel & Eshel 2005 (= Accordance) Tov 2010: 28. Tov (2010: 110) also seems to label this fragment X20 (XIsa) William Kando → Lee Biondi & Bruce Ferrini † ➤ William Noah (June 2004)
49 Isa 28:23–29 William Kando
50 Jer 3:15–19 MS 4612/9
DSS F.116 (Jer1)
Wrongly identified as 4Q71 (4QJerb) by Hanan Eshel. Tov (2010: 110, 128) seems to label it X21 (XJer) and Elgvin (2016) labels it 4Q(?)Jer William Kando Schøyen Collection (2009)
51 Jer 23:6–9 motb.scr.003172
DSS F.195 (Jer2)
William Kando ➤ Steve Green  Museum of the Bible (May 2010)
52 Jer 24:6–7 (Eshel & Eshel 2007)
Jer 48:29–31 (Puech?; Charlesworth 2010)
 DSS F.156 (Jer3)  Wrongly identified as 4Q72 (4QJerc) frg. 21a 1–3 by Eshel & Eshel 2007 (=Accordance)   Tov 2010: 29

William Kando → Lee Biondi & Bruce Ferrini † ➤ William Noah (June 2004)

Michael Sharpe →  Foundation on Judaism and Christian Origins

53 Ezek 28:22 motb.scr.003174
DSS F.196 (Ezek1)
William Kando ➤ Steve Green  Museum of the Bible (May 2010)
54 Dan 5:13–16 APU5
DSS F.155 (Dan1)
 X23 (XDan) (Tov 2010: 110, 129) Michael R. Thompson – Lee Biondi ➤
Azusa Pacific University  (Aug 2009)
55 Dan 6:22–24 DSS F.166 (Dan2)  Wrongly identified  (and sold?) as 6QpapDan
X24 (XpapDan) (Tov 2010: 110, 129)
William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary (Jan 2010)
56 Dan 7:18–19 DSS F.167 (Dan3) William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary (Jan 2010)
57 Dan 10:18–20 motb.scr.003170
DSS F.200 (Dan6)
William Kando ➤ Steve Green  Museum of the Bible (May 2010)
58 Joel 4:9–10 William Kando
59 Amos 3:4–5 Identified by Hanan and Esther Eshel in 2005 William Kando ➤ Craig Lampe (? 20022004?) Ron Wicks (? 2004)
60 Amos 7:17–8:1 (3 frgs) DSS F.181 (Amos1) Original Dead Sea Scroll Fragment William Kando ➤ Mark W. Lanier (2013)
61 Jona 4:2–5 motb.scr.003171
DSS F.197 (Jon1)
William Kando ➤ Steve Green  Museum of the Bible (May 2010)
62 Mic 1:4–6 motb.scr.003183
DSS F.198 (Mic1)
William Kando ➤ Steve Green  Museum of the Bible (May 2010)
63 Tob 7:1–3 XpapTobit ar William Kando ( Devorah Dimant)
64 Tob 14:3–4 MS 5234
DSS F.123 (Tob1)
 Wrongly identified as 4Q196 (4QpapTobita ar) frg. 18a by Hallermayer & Elgvin 2006 → Tov 2010: 35, and thereafter as 4Q196a by Elgvin 2012 William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2003)
65 1 En. 7:1–5 MS 4612/8
DSS F.124 (En1)
 Wrongly identified as 4Q204 (4QEnochc ar) by Esther Eshel (2009). Tov (2010: 37) says it’s possibly a frg of 4Q203 (4QEnGiantsa ar), but also labels it XQEnocha (p. 37) and X27 (XEnb ar) (p. 110) William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2009)
66 1 En. 8:4–9:3 MS 4612/12
DSS F.125 (En2)
 Wrongly labelled XQpapEnoch by Eshel & Eshel 2004 → XQ8 (XQpapEn)  by Parry & Tov 2005 (= Accordance) + Parry & Tov 2014(!), and X26 (XpapEna) by Tov 2010: 110 William Kando (Bruce Ferrini → Esther & Hanan Eshel) ➤ Schøyen Collection (2009)
67 1 En. 106:19–107:1 MS 4612/6
DSS F.126 (En3)
X28 (XEnc ar)? (Tov 2010: 110) William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (April 2009)
68 = 4Q418 ii 4–5 Motb.scr.000123
DSS F.202 (Instr1)
Wrongly identified as 4Q416 (4QInstructionb) frg. 23 by Eshel & Eshel 2007 → Tov 2010: 50 William Kando ➤ Craig (& Joel) Lampe (2003–4) ➤ Green Collection (November 2009) → Museum of the Bible
69 “4Q418”  W 16 William Kando? (→ Lee Biondi & Joel Lampe?)
70 Fragment with text from the Temple Scroll  4QTemple (K)a (Fields)
Par 11Q19 LIV 21 – LV 06
William Kando ( Lawrence Schiffman)
71 Fragment with text from the Temple Scroll  4QTemple (K)b (Fields)
Par 11Q19 LVI 06 – LVI 7
William Kando ( Lawrence Schiffman)
72 Comm Gen A MS 5095/7
DSS F.130 (Comm Gen)
 Fragment with Text from 4QCommentary on Genesis A William Kando ➤ Schøyen Collection (2010)
73 Unidentified MS 5439/2
DSS F.132
William Kando ➤
Schøyen Collection
74 Unidentified The Loveless fragment
DSS F.168 (Text1)
William Kando ➤ Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary (Sep 2010)
75 Unidentified (“remains of 7 lines in Greek and remains of semitic letters of the cursive Aramaic type in a perpendicular direction”) W 17 William Kando ➤ Bruce Ferrini (?)
76–77 Unidentified “Manuscript fragments in Hebrew on brown leather, beginning of a scroll with characters in a fine Herodian Hebrew Book Script. Qumran, Late 1st Century A.D. Identified by Professor Emil Puesch [sic], Ecole de Biblioteque, Jerusalem [sic]” Special Visit Ministry
78 Unidentified SIG.SCR.004741 Andrew Stimer ➤  Steve Green (Oct 2014-June 2015)→ Museum of the Bible
79 Unidentified SIG.00SCR.4768 Andrew Stimer ➤ Steve Green (Oct 2014-June 2015)→ Museum of the Bible
80 Unidentified SIG.SCR.004769 Andrew Stimer ➤ Steve Green (Oct 2014-June 2015)→ Museum of the Bible
Scraps Unidentified (Greek and/or Hebrew letters?) 3 frgs plus 2 frag. sets, totaling 15 frgs William Kando(?) → Bruce Ferrini(?) → Les Enluminures ➤ undisclosed U.S. institution

5 thoughts on “A List of Unprovenanced, Post-2002 Dead Sea Scrolls-like Fragments

Leave a Reply to Manuscrits de la mer Morte : nouveaux fragments | Didier Fontaine Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.